Difference between revisions of "Overview of Luanti forks"

From Luanti Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(rename Minetest to Luanti)
 
(24 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
A software is said to be a '''fork''' if it is a derivation of a copy of another software; that is, if it is based on its source code and other related data. Minetest has seen some forks in its history. This article gives an overview of some of the known forks of Minetest.
+
{{Languages|nocat=1}}
  
−
== What is a Minetest fork? ==
+
A software is said to be a '''fork''' if it is a derivation of a copy of another software; that is, if it is based on its source code and other related data. Luanti has seen some forks in its history. This article gives an overview of some of the known forks of Luanti.
−
As said, above, a fork is another copy of software that is edited. For Minetest, it is the same. Except a few mods put together is not called a fork, that would be a modpack. A fork is a Core engine change(s) that are not official and will not be released as a version of Minetest unless submitted and accepted in a pull request.
 
  
−
== Active projects ==
+
== What is a Luanti fork? ==
 +
As said, above, a fork is another copy of software that is edited. For Luanti, it is the same. Except a few mods put together is not called a fork, that would be a modpack. A fork is a Core engine change(s) that are not official and will not be released as a version of Luanti unless submitted and accepted in a pull request.
  
−
The following projects are known to be actively developed.
+
== List of projects ==
  
−
=== Freeminer ===
+
The following projects are known Luanti forks, which may or may not be active at the moment.
  
−
'''[http://freeminer.org/ Freeminer]''' is a fork of Minetest version 0.4.8.
+
=== Voxelands ===
  
−
The project goals are vaguely described as something along the lines of “To create a fun and playable game” and it is unclear what has motivated the fork. A list of changes compared to Minetest was published: [http://forum.freeminer.org/threads/full-list-of-changes-from-minetest.110/]
+
'''[http://www.voxelands.com/ Voxelands]''' was started under the name “Minetest Classic” on the 15th of April 2013 (date of [https://gitorious.org/minetest-classic/minetest-classic/commit/2c4e0bcbc94abca621aeaa6f5159d2637179da47 earliest recorded commit]) by darkrose as a fork of the latest stable release of the 0.3 series of Minetest-c55 (“Minetest-c55” was the earlier name of Luanti).
  
−
=== Minetest Classic ===
+
The fork was motivated by a dissatisfaction of Luanti becoming more and more a game engine rather than a game. Voxelands developers also claim that with the start of 0.4 series (and the introduction of the [[Mods|Lua modding API]]), Luanti has decreased in performance, which is another key motivation for Voxelands. Voxelands is incompatible with Luanti and now quite different.
  
−
'''[http://minetest-classic.com/ Minetest Classic]''' was started in April 15 2013 (date of [https://gitorious.org/minetest-classic/minetest-classic/commit/2c4e0bcbc94abca621aeaa6f5159d2637179da47 earliest recorded commit]) by darkrose as a fork of the latest stable release of the 0.3 series of Minetest-c55 (“Minetest-c55” was the earlier name of Minetest).
+
Key goals of Voxelands are keeping the game at least as performant as the Minetest-c55 0.3 series, adding new content, maintaining balanced gameplay with a focus of in-world functionality, backporting bugfixes and some features from the 0.4 series and maintaining backwards compatibility to the 0.3 series at the network protocol level.
  
−
The fork was motivated by a dissatisfaction of Minetest becoming more and more a game engine rather than a game. Minetest Classic developers also claim that with the start of 0.4 series (and the introduction of the [[Mods|Lua modding API]]), Minetest has decrease in performance, which is another key motivation for Minetest Classic.
+
=== Blocklife ===
 +
[https://forum.minetest.net/viewtopic.php?f=14&t=12021 Blocklife] was first announced on the Luanti forum on Thu Apr 30, 2015 by gibucsoft. It started with only few noticeable changes to version 0.4.7 and came with a game that included some more mods than Minetst Game. The most interesting feature was the use of two hands that could each be used seperately. On 23th May 2018 gibucsoft anounced to once more start developing. This time the block size might get reduced to a tenth in sidelength. The goal would be to have a more reallistic shaped “round” world.
  
−
Key goals of Minetest Classic are keeping the game at least as performant as the Minetest-c55 0.3 series, backporting bugfixes and some features from the 0.4 series and maintaining backwards compatibility to the 0.3 series. However, the goal of backwards compatibility may be dropped in the future.
+
=== Freeminer ===
  
−
== Inactive projects ==
+
'''[http://freeminer.org/ Freeminer]''' is a fork of version 0.4.8. It's no longer maintained.
  
−
There are also forks of Minetest which eventually withered and died. These projects are not actively developed anymore.
+
The project goals have been vaguely described as something along the lines of “To create a fun and playable game” and it is unclear what has motivated the fork. A list of changes compared to Luanti was published: [http://forum.freeminer.org/threads/full-list-of-changes-from-minetest.110/]
 +
 
 +
[https://f-droid.org/packages/org.freeminer.freeminer/ Freeminer is also available for Android], but it's no longer maintained either.  
  
 
=== Minetest-delta ===
 
=== Minetest-delta ===
  
−
'''Minetest-delta''' was a fork of Minetest, maintained in mid-2011, with the goal of adding more experimental features to Minetest. Some contributions like papyrus, cacti and jungles have since been merged in Minetest.
+
[https://github.com/erlehmann/minetest-delta Minetest-delta] was a fork of Luanti, maintained in mid-2011, with the goal of adding more experimental features to Luanti. Some contributions like papyrus, cacti and jungles have since been merged in Luanti.
  
 
=== Minetest-M13 ===
 
=== Minetest-M13 ===
  
−
No activity recorded since 2012.
+
An ancient fork. No activity recorded since 2012.
 +
[[Category:Related software]]
 +
 
 +
=== Various forks of the Android version ===
 +
There are a lot of Android forks. Sadly, there are a lot of low-quality proprietary Luanti forks. Many of them are known to have extremely annoying advertisements (which often make the game near-unplayable) or even in-app-purchases. '''Those are not part of official Luanti!'''
 +
 
 +
The ''official'' Android versions can be found here:
 +
 
 +
* [https://f-droid.org/packages/net.minetest.minetest/ Luanti on F-Droid]
 +
* [https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.minetest.minetest Luanti on Google Play]
 +
 
 +
'''Important: Ads, in-app purchases or other anti-features are not, and will never be part of Luanti!''' If you see ads, double-check if you have ''really'' installed Luanti, and not something else. Luanti is a community-driven free software project and we are way too proud of ourselves to ever need something like ads or in-app-purchases. :D
 +
 
 +
Many of these Luanti forks come and go rather quickly. Here are some known names in Google Play (because it changes so quickly, this list ls likely outdated and incomplete):
 +
 
 +
* Worldcraft: Exploration Lite
 +
* WorldCraft 2 : Pocket Edition
 +
* PixelCraft — 3D Survival!
 +
* ► MultiCraft ― Free Miner!
 +
* Crazy Craft on Castle World PE
 +
* MultiCraft - Minetest France
 +
* Cartoon Craft: Castle World PE
 +
* Voxel Craft : Castle Build PE
 +
* World Craft 3D
 +
* Squeake Craft PLUS
 +
 
 +
[https://forum.minetest.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=16707 Discussion thread].
 +
 
 +
Not much is known about these forks so far (feel free to edit this wiki page!). But we do know all these forks are illegetimate proprietary forks and/or they contain anti-features such as ads. For most of these, there's no source code provided, there's a proprietary license or no license at all. None of these problems exist in Luanti.
 +
 
 +
Note we are absolutely not against unofficial forks of Luanti and creating awesome new things with it (that's the whole point of being free software!).
 +
But for Android, we simply have not been impressed by the results so far. However, if you think you found a great Luanti fork for Android, please tell us in the [https://forum.minetest.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=16707 forums].
 +
 
 +
If you want to avoid proprietary forks with annoying anti-features altogether, we recommend you start to use [https://f-droid.org/ F-Droid] instead of Google Play. F-Droid software is a repository maintained by free software zealots like us in which fishy proprietary software is not allowed in the first place. :-)
 +
 
 +
=== Various forks of the iOS version ===
 +
Just like with Android, we also had people forking Luanti for iOS. The similar problems apply here.
 +
 
 +
Here's a list (we can't recommend any of these):
 +
 
 +
* [https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/buildcraft-multiplayer-block-game/id740372768?mt=8 Buildcraft]
 +
* [https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/worldcraft-survival-2/id900353132?mt=8 Worldcraft 2]
 +
* [https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/worldcraft-pocket-edition/id796349324?mt=8 Worldcraft Pocket Edition]
 +
* [https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/exploration-mind-world-of-craft-survival-game/id880642020?mt=8 Exploration]
 +
* FreeCraft (No iTunes Store link at the moment)
 +
 
 +
None of these are free software either. Buildcraft even forces you to perform an in-app purchases to make its ads go away.
 +
 
 +
[https://forum.minetest.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=16707 Discussion thread].

Latest revision as of 22:51, 22 October 2024

Languages Language: English • 日本語

A software is said to be a fork if it is a derivation of a copy of another software; that is, if it is based on its source code and other related data. Luanti has seen some forks in its history. This article gives an overview of some of the known forks of Luanti.

What is a Luanti fork?

As said, above, a fork is another copy of software that is edited. For Luanti, it is the same. Except a few mods put together is not called a fork, that would be a modpack. A fork is a Core engine change(s) that are not official and will not be released as a version of Luanti unless submitted and accepted in a pull request.

List of projects

The following projects are known Luanti forks, which may or may not be active at the moment.

Voxelands

Voxelands was started under the name “Minetest Classic” on the 15th of April 2013 (date of earliest recorded commit) by darkrose as a fork of the latest stable release of the 0.3 series of Minetest-c55 (“Minetest-c55” was the earlier name of Luanti).

The fork was motivated by a dissatisfaction of Luanti becoming more and more a game engine rather than a game. Voxelands developers also claim that with the start of 0.4 series (and the introduction of the Lua modding API), Luanti has decreased in performance, which is another key motivation for Voxelands. Voxelands is incompatible with Luanti and now quite different.

Key goals of Voxelands are keeping the game at least as performant as the Minetest-c55 0.3 series, adding new content, maintaining balanced gameplay with a focus of in-world functionality, backporting bugfixes and some features from the 0.4 series and maintaining backwards compatibility to the 0.3 series at the network protocol level.

Blocklife

Blocklife was first announced on the Luanti forum on Thu Apr 30, 2015 by gibucsoft. It started with only few noticeable changes to version 0.4.7 and came with a game that included some more mods than Minetst Game. The most interesting feature was the use of two hands that could each be used seperately. On 23th May 2018 gibucsoft anounced to once more start developing. This time the block size might get reduced to a tenth in sidelength. The goal would be to have a more reallistic shaped “round” world.

Freeminer

Freeminer is a fork of version 0.4.8. It's no longer maintained.

The project goals have been vaguely described as something along the lines of “To create a fun and playable game” and it is unclear what has motivated the fork. A list of changes compared to Luanti was published: [1]

Freeminer is also available for Android, but it's no longer maintained either.

Minetest-delta

Minetest-delta was a fork of Luanti, maintained in mid-2011, with the goal of adding more experimental features to Luanti. Some contributions like papyrus, cacti and jungles have since been merged in Luanti.

Minetest-M13

An ancient fork. No activity recorded since 2012.

Various forks of the Android version

There are a lot of Android forks. Sadly, there are a lot of low-quality proprietary Luanti forks. Many of them are known to have extremely annoying advertisements (which often make the game near-unplayable) or even in-app-purchases. Those are not part of official Luanti!

The official Android versions can be found here:

Important: Ads, in-app purchases or other anti-features are not, and will never be part of Luanti! If you see ads, double-check if you have really installed Luanti, and not something else. Luanti is a community-driven free software project and we are way too proud of ourselves to ever need something like ads or in-app-purchases. :D

Many of these Luanti forks come and go rather quickly. Here are some known names in Google Play (because it changes so quickly, this list ls likely outdated and incomplete):

  • Worldcraft: Exploration Lite
  • WorldCraft 2 : Pocket Edition
  • PixelCraft — 3D Survival!
  • ► MultiCraft ― Free Miner!
  • Crazy Craft on Castle World PE
  • MultiCraft - Minetest France
  • Cartoon Craft: Castle World PE
  • Voxel Craft : Castle Build PE
  • World Craft 3D
  • Squeake Craft PLUS

Discussion thread.

Not much is known about these forks so far (feel free to edit this wiki page!). But we do know all these forks are illegetimate proprietary forks and/or they contain anti-features such as ads. For most of these, there's no source code provided, there's a proprietary license or no license at all. None of these problems exist in Luanti.

Note we are absolutely not against unofficial forks of Luanti and creating awesome new things with it (that's the whole point of being free software!). But for Android, we simply have not been impressed by the results so far. However, if you think you found a great Luanti fork for Android, please tell us in the forums.

If you want to avoid proprietary forks with annoying anti-features altogether, we recommend you start to use F-Droid instead of Google Play. F-Droid software is a repository maintained by free software zealots like us in which fishy proprietary software is not allowed in the first place. :-)

Various forks of the iOS version

Just like with Android, we also had people forking Luanti for iOS. The similar problems apply here.

Here's a list (we can't recommend any of these):

None of these are free software either. Buildcraft even forces you to perform an in-app purchases to make its ads go away.

Discussion thread.

Retrieved from "http://wiki.luanti.org/index.php?title=Overview_of_Luanti_forks&oldid=28436"